|
|
|
date: Tue, 30 Sep 2008 22:31:07 +0100,
group: uk.rec.cars.maintenance
back
Lack of engine power - possible causes?
My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have lost a
lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive and
although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill. Some
thoughts:
- It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
- As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
- It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
- The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or run
roughly or lumpily.
- I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
pipes I can see
Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
- Blocked fuel injector
- Spark plugs
- Fuel filter or pump (??)
- Ignition timing
So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in mind
the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come on quite
suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
3. Oxygen sensor problems?
4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
Thanks
Steve
date: Tue, 30 Sep 2008 22:31:07 +0100
author: Steve W
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
Steve W wrote:
> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have
> lost a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test
> drive and although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially
> uphill. Some thoughts:
>
> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire,
> or run roughly or lumpily.
> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the
> air/vacuum pipes I can see
>
> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
> - Blocked fuel injector
> - Spark plugs
> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
> - Ignition timing
>
> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in
> mind the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come
> on quite suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>
> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
>
> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
> Thanks
> Steve
Air filter, blocked exhaust (broken cat is very common), cam timing slipped
a tooth. These would be the first things to check.
date: Tue, 30 Sep 2008 21:42:04 GMT
author: Mrcheerful
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
On Tue, 30 Sep 2008 22:31:07 +0100, Steve W
wrote:
> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have
> lost a
> lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive and
> although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill. Some
> thoughts:
>
> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or
> run
> roughly or lumpily.
> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
> pipes I can see
>
> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
> - Blocked fuel injector
> - Spark plugs
> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
> - Ignition timing
>
> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in mind
> the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come on quite
> suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>
> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
Very Unlikely.
> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
Unlikely, & you'd normally get a fault code
> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
Possibly , but you'd get a fault code
> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
Cold start sensor/ Air temp sensor
> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
You can play hunt with some wd40 easily
> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
Cam belt's jumped, or exhaust/cat blocked as Mr Cheerful says, an air leak
that only opens when the engine moves on its mounts.
>
> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
> Thanks
> Steve
>
>
>
>
>
date: Tue, 30 Sep 2008 23:54:22 +0100
author: Duncan Wood
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
"Steve W" wrote in message
news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have lost
> a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive and
> although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill. Some
> thoughts:
>
> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or
> run roughly or lumpily.
> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
> pipes I can see
>
If it has EGR it might be worth checking the valve or even taking it off and
cleaning it.
Or, depending how it operates, disable it temporarily to see if it's
anything to do with the problem.
date: Wed, 1 Oct 2008 08:46:05 +0100
author: Mark W s@o
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
Mark W wrote:
> "Steve W" wrote in message
> news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
>> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have
>> lost a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a
>> test drive and although it's drivable it certainly struggles,
>> especially uphill. Some thoughts:
>>
>> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
>> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
>> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
>> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge,
>> misfire, or run roughly or lumpily.
>> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the
>> air/vacuum pipes I can see
>>
>
>
> If it has EGR it might be worth checking the valve or even taking it
> off and cleaning it.
> Or, depending how it operates, disable it temporarily to see if it's
> anything to do with the problem.
usually egr fault is low speed problem, flat out there is no real
difference.
years ago a friend had a Cortina that he used as a taxi, it burnt oil
through the stem seals, eventually it built up so much crud on the back of
the valves that power was well down, one day a valve's worth fell off,
holding the valve open, that was when it got taken to bits and everything
became clear.
CVH engines suffer from seal problems, so perhaps that is what is happening
here?
date: Wed, 01 Oct 2008 08:03:50 GMT
author: Mrcheerful
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
"Steve W" wrote in message
news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have lost
> a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive and
> although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill. Some
> thoughts:
>
> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or
> run roughly or lumpily.
> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
> pipes I can see
>
> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
> - Blocked fuel injector
> - Spark plugs
> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
> - Ignition timing
>
> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in mind
> the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come on quite
> suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>
> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
>
> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
> Thanks
> Steve
>
>
>
>
>
I had a very similar problem with mine. Turned out to be a blocked Cat.
Gareth.
date: Wed, 1 Oct 2008 10:12:32 +0100
author: Gareth Magennis
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes?
"Gareth Magennis" wrote in message
news:68CdnXDowK6don7VnZ2dnUVZ8sbinZ2d@bt.com...
>
> "Steve W" wrote in message
> news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
>> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have lost
>> a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive
>> and although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill.
>> Some thoughts:
>>
>> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
>> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
>> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
>> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or
>> run roughly or lumpily.
>> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
>> pipes I can see
>>
>> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
>> - Blocked fuel injector
>> - Spark plugs
>> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
>> - Ignition timing
>>
>> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in mind
>> the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come on quite
>> suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>>
>> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
>> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
>> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
>> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
>> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
>> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
>>
>> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
>> Thanks
>> Steve
>>
>
> I had a very similar problem with mine. Turned out to be a blocked Cat.
>
> Gareth.
Ditto ditto, my daughter's Mundano ... seemed quite happy idling, low revs,
or small throttle openings, but had no pulling power and struggled on hills.
Definitely worth a check, I'd say ...
date: Wed, 1 Oct 2008 16:00:55 +0100
author: Mike Faithfull
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? UPDATE
"Steve W" wrote in message
news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have lost
> a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a test drive and
> although it's drivable it certainly struggles, especially uphill. Some
> thoughts:
>
> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge, misfire, or
> run roughly or lumpily.
> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the air/vacuum
> pipes I can see
>
> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
> - Blocked fuel injector
> - Spark plugs
> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
> - Ignition timing
>
> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in mind
> the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come on quite
> suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>
> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
>
> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
> Thanks
> Steve
>
Original Poster here. Thanks to all for replying with your ideas. There's
one other bit of info I should have posted earlier. A couple of days before
my daughter reported the problem, I had changed the exhaust system seal
(ring joint) which was just upstream of the Cat. It was blowing noisily and
when I opened the joint, the seal was clearly breaking up quite badly. I
pulled out the joint, which had some missing bits, and replaced with a new
sealing ring. I had assumed that any fragments from the seal would have
blown out of the system. But now I'm starting to wonder if something had
got to the Cat.
Anyway, I need to look more closely at the Cat. How do check it out without
special tools? I assume I could check the pressure before the Cat, or the
pressure drop across it? And would I need to measure the temperature
upstream and downstream of the Cat?
Can I clean a cat, once I've got it out of the car? How?
I see I can get a replacement cat for around £50. Is that likely to be the
best solution if I have any doubts about the condition of the existing Cat?
Steve
date: Wed, 1 Oct 2008 23:40:08 +0100
author: Steve W
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? UPDATE
Steve W wrote:
> "Steve W" wrote in message
> news:tvSdnSJw2P0AB3_VRVnyggA@giganews.com...
>> My daughter's 1997 Ford Escort 1.4 with fuel injection seems to have
>> lost a lot of power over a fairly short period of time. I did a
>> test drive and although it's drivable it certainly struggles,
>> especially uphill. Some thoughts:
>>
>> - It starts OK and idles reasonably well, without hunting.
>> - As the engine speed is increased, the power just isn't there.
>> - It is not the clutch slipping or the brakes binding.
>> - The engine still runs fairly smoothly - it does not surge,
>> misfire, or run roughly or lumpily.
>> - I can't hear an obvious air leak, and have wiggled all the
>> air/vacuum pipes I can see
>>
>> Because of the above, I'm guessing it's NOT:
>> - Blocked fuel injector
>> - Spark plugs
>> - Fuel filter or pump (??)
>> - Ignition timing
>>
>> So.....what are your theories, in priority order, please, bearing in
>> mind the above observations and the fact that it seems to have come
>> on quite suddenly? Here's my speculative list for starters:
>>
>> 1. Electronic Control Unit (ECU)
>> 2. Fuel Pressure Regulator
>> 3. Oxygen sensor problems?
>> 4. Some other sensor (eg. temperature) that feeds the ECU
>> 5. Vaccum leak that I haven't found
>> 6. ...er, that's it. I've run out of ideas
>>
>> I ( and my daughter) would appreciate any help you can give.
>> Thanks
>> Steve
>>
>
> Original Poster here. Thanks to all for replying with your ideas. There's
> one other bit of info I should have posted earlier. A couple
> of days before my daughter reported the problem, I had changed the
> exhaust system seal (ring joint) which was just upstream of the Cat. It
> was blowing noisily and when I opened the joint, the seal was
> clearly breaking up quite badly. I pulled out the joint, which had
> some missing bits, and replaced with a new sealing ring. I had
> assumed that any fragments from the seal would have blown out of the
> system. But now I'm starting to wonder if something had got to the
> Cat.
> Anyway, I need to look more closely at the Cat. How do check it out
> without special tools? I assume I could check the pressure before
> the Cat, or the pressure drop across it? And would I need to measure
> the temperature upstream and downstream of the Cat?
>
> Can I clean a cat, once I've got it out of the car? How?
>
> I see I can get a replacement cat for around £50. Is that likely to
> be the best solution if I have any doubts about the condition of the
> existing Cat?
> Steve
The blow eould have been letting enough gases through, fixing it has made
everything go through the rest of the exhaust, if it is blocked then it
can't run right. There is a way of testing with back pressure in the pipe.
Taking the cat off and blowing through it 'may' confirm it, rattling bits is
definite. 50 quid is cheap. If you dare run and drive it it with the
exhaust off then the blocked cat diagnosis is easier !!
Mrcheerful
date: Thu, 02 Oct 2008 07:13:36 GMT
author: Mrcheerful
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? UPDATE
"Mrcheerful" wrote in message
news:Aw_Ek.65492$E41.63351@text.news.virginmedia.com...
> > The blow eould have been letting enough gases through, fixing it has
> > made
> everything go through the rest of the exhaust, if it is blocked then it
> can't run right. There is a way of testing with back pressure in the
> pipe. Taking the cat off and blowing through it 'may' confirm it, rattling
> bits is definite. 50 quid is cheap. If you dare run and drive it it
> with the exhaust off then the blocked cat diagnosis is easier !!
>
> Mrcheerful
OK, if you are within 50 miles of Darlington you may hear a couple of test
runs on Saturday morning!. I'm near the airport so will try to coincide my
tests with take-offs.
date: Thu, 2 Oct 2008 20:46:57 +0100
author: Steve W
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? UPDATE
On Thu, 02 Oct 2008 07:13:36 +0000, Mrcheerful wrote:
> The blow eould have been letting enough gases through, fixing it has
> made everything go through the rest of the exhaust, if it is blocked
> then it can't run right. There is a way of testing with back pressure
> in the pipe. Taking the cat off and blowing through it 'may' confirm it,
> rattling bits is definite. 50 quid is cheap. If you dare run and drive
> it it with the exhaust off then the blocked cat diagnosis is easier !!
Could be that a blocked cat caused the gases to find their own way out
and that's what started and enlarged the blow and broken up seal in the
first place...
date: Sat, 04 Oct 2008 18:23:18 GMT
author: PCPaul
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? - FINAL UPDATE
"PCPaul" wrote in message
news:qwOFk.66777$E41.12415@text.news.virginmedia.com...
> On Thu, 02 Oct 2008 07:13:36 +0000, Mrcheerful wrote:
>
>> The blow eould have been letting enough gases through, fixing it has
>> made everything go through the rest of the exhaust, if it is blocked
>> then it can't run right. There is a way of testing with back pressure
>> in the pipe. Taking the cat off and blowing through it 'may' confirm it,
>> rattling bits is definite. 50 quid is cheap. If you dare run and drive
>> it it with the exhaust off then the blocked cat diagnosis is easier !!
>
> Could be that a blocked cat caused the gases to find their own way out
> and that's what started and enlarged the blow and broken up seal in the
> first place...
Yup, it seems that's what might have happened. Bits had definitely come
loose inside. Changed the Cat (£56 inc VAT, if anyone is interested), and
the poor old engine has gor a new lease of life.
THANKS TO EVERYONE for pointing me in the right direction. Aren't
newsgroups great?
Best wishes
Steve
date: Sat, 4 Oct 2008 23:36:21 +0100
author: Steve W
|
Re: Lack of engine power - possible causes? - FINAL UPDATE
Steve W wrote:
> "PCPaul" wrote in message
> news:qwOFk.66777$E41.12415@text.news.virginmedia.com...
>> On Thu, 02 Oct 2008 07:13:36 +0000, Mrcheerful wrote:
>>
>>> The blow eould have been letting enough gases through, fixing it has
>>> made everything go through the rest of the exhaust, if it is blocked
>>> then it can't run right. There is a way of testing with back
>>> pressure in the pipe. Taking the cat off and blowing through it
>>> 'may' confirm it, rattling bits is definite. 50 quid is cheap. If
>>> you dare run and drive it it with the exhaust off then the blocked
>>> cat diagnosis is easier !!
>>
>> Could be that a blocked cat caused the gases to find their own way
>> out and that's what started and enlarged the blow and broken up seal
>> in the first place...
>
> Yup, it seems that's what might have happened. Bits had definitely
> come loose inside. Changed the Cat (£56 inc VAT, if anyone is
> interested), and the poor old engine has gor a new lease of life.
>
> THANKS TO EVERYONE for pointing me in the right direction. Aren't
> newsgroups great?
>
> Best wishes
> Steve
don't forget to take the old cat in for scrap. 20 -40 pounds worth
date: Sun, 05 Oct 2008 08:35:53 GMT
author: Mrcheerful
|
|
|