So if the season finished now who would be here and who would be gone. 
after today's game I can see a number of players leaving, some 
departures that would shock some toon fans

Shay Given: Been at the club a long time and has been good for us may be 
great, but he has made some mistakes and it looks like he has never 
recovered from his injury last season. Also he never seems to talk to 
the defence, telling them to clear the ball or push out. Which a 
goalkeeper should be doing

Stephen Carr: plan and simple he has to go
	
Jose Enrique: Bought by sam and never played, played under kk a couple 
of games but I think he will be leaving
	
David Rozehnal: Another player who has flattered to deceive. I think going.

Emre: He has to stay, he could be good for us but he needs a holding 
player to get the best out of him.

Cacapa: He is so laid back it scary, but saying that he has come in and 
made some good tackles when others have froze. but I would say going
	
Obafemi Martins: we have to keep him, we need speed and he has it. Under 
Keegan he would become a good finisher in front of goal.
	
Michael Owen: We also have to keep him, might not have the pace but will 
be there in the box 9 times out of 10.

Damien Duff: Stay, he needs a good left back behind so he can go on the 
runs he used to at other clubs

Stephen Harper: Stay, he has to be given his shot in the team. Between 
him and given they are too close to call. But I feel harper is better at 
some things and given is better at others.
	
Charles N'Zogbia: He is a jem but not for the first time he (his agent) 
has said the player is unhappy for personal reasons. His form has been 
off this season because he's played at left back. Sell him I don't know 
but I would think if we did we would ask a fair bit for him.

James Milner: Stay, with him and duff we have at least 2 good wingers or 
wide men.

Alan Smith: what is his role, sell him

Geremi: sell

Habib Beye: keep, he is a good right back. lets hope we can keep him

Nicholas Butt: starting to slow, may be it's time to let him go. sell

Ameobi: Sell, sell, sell

Abdoulaye Faye: sell

Peter Ramage:keep as back up for now

Steven Taylor: keep, give him a 5 year contract and make him captain 
next season

David Edgar: keep as back up

Fraser Forster: Keep as back up

Ben Tozer: back up player 	
Mark Viduka: Sell, will never win over kk 	
James Troisi: keep 	

Kazenga LuaLua: keep
	
Andrew Carroll: keep
	
Tim Krul: keep

so what do you guys think, who would you keep or get rid of

Rozenhal has gone on loan to Lazio and will move permanently in the summer.

Carr is,as has been for a long time,the new Bramble.Are the supporters 
the only ones to see how crap this player is in the team week in week out.
I know about his injury but he was no great shakes before that.
We had more effort from Ramage and I still would like to see Taylor and 
Ramgage given a try in center back positions.
Can't be worse than those last three goals at Villa.

"braves1212@tiscali.co.uk"  wrote in message 
news:47aed698$1_4@mk-nntp-2.news.uk.tiscali.com...
> Carr is,as has been for a long time,the new Bramble.Are the supporters the 
> only ones to see how crap this player is in the team week in week out.
> I know about his injury but he was no great shakes before that.
> We had more effort from Ramage and I still would like to see Taylor and 
> Ramgage given a try in center back positions.
> Can't be worse than those last three goals at Villa.


To get the players to go to a shite team like Newcastle requires huge wages, 
the players won't leave unless their contracts are fully paid up.