Myreader.co.uk  
uk news, chat and community
   home   |   control panel login   |   archive   |  
 
politics
animals
announce
censorship
constitution
crime
drugs
economics
electoral
environment
guns
misc
parliament
philosophy
  
 
date: Fri, 13 Jan 2006 17:31:49 +0000,    group: uk.politics.censorship        back       
Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
Shock and gore
By James Harkin
http://news.ft.com/cms/s/1373c930-8325-11da-ac1f-0000779e2340.html

Here's a choice quote from the article:

"But viewing Ogrish throws up some thorny moral dilemmas. In the past
few years, western governments have cracked down on child pornography
distributed via the internet. Watching sexualised images of children
from the comfort of one’s personal computer is morally repugnant, but
it is not the same as abusing children. The rationale for sending
people to jail for viewing such images is that their perverse
appetites feed the production of those images, and indirectly the
abuse of children.

"If so, then there is an argument that we are equally culpable when we
watch life being snuffed out on websites such as Ogrish. The lesson
here is not that we should ban Ogrish, but that we have not yet worked
out what kind of beast the world wide web is, or the responsibilities
required of those who use it."

Rather a mealy-mouthed conclusion I think, trying to have it both ways
- apparently some of the violence is staged for the camera.

-- 
Brave New Britain
date: Fri, 13 Jan 2006 17:31:49 +0000   author:   Brave New Britain

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
Iraqis are not quite the backward camel humping wogs that Blair, Bush
and the Jewish controlled Western media would have you believe are
they?
date: 13 Jan 2006 09:53:27 -0800   author:   Just Another Legal Fan

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
On Fri, 13 Jan 2006 17:31:49 +0000, Brave New Britain 
wrote:

>Shock and gore
>By James Harkin
>http://news.ft.com/cms/s/1373c930-8325-11da-ac1f-0000779e2340.html
>
>Here's a choice quote from the article:
>
>"But viewing Ogrish throws up some thorny moral dilemmas. In the past
>few years, western governments have cracked down on child pornography
>distributed via the internet. Watching sexualised images of children
>from the comfort of one’s personal computer is morally repugnant, but
>it is not the same as abusing children. The rationale for sending
>people to jail for viewing such images is that their perverse
>appetites feed the production of those images, and indirectly the
>abuse of children.
>
>"If so, then there is an argument that we are equally culpable when we
>watch life being snuffed out on websites such as Ogrish. The lesson
>here is not that we should ban Ogrish, but that we have not yet worked
>out what kind of beast the world wide web is, or the responsibilities
>required of those who use it."
>
>Rather a mealy-mouthed conclusion I think, trying to have it both ways
>- apparently some of the violence is staged for the camera.


Well, download pics of topless 17 year old = sick pervert, on to the
SOR and don't ever think of working with children

Download full colour videos of people being tortured, maimed or killed
= no problem!

If people hadn't ground Ogrish to a halt to download the Nick Berg
beheading video then maybe Ken Bigley wouldn't have suffered the same
fate. Therefore I say we round up all the several hundred thousand
sickos in this country who viewed it and charge them before putting
them on some sort of violent offenders register.
date: Fri, 13 Jan 2006 23:12:53 +0000   author:   ed

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
"Just Another Legal Fan"  wrote in message
news:1137174807.088543.245100@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
> Iraqis are not quite the backward camel humping wogs that Blair, Bush
> and the Jewish controlled Western media would have you believe are
> they?

I wonder how things would have turned out in Iraq if the Americans didn't
have any air power there, and just fought the Iraqis man to man...
date: Sat, 14 Jan 2006 00:57:42 GMT   author:   unknown

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
ed wrote:
>
> Well, download pics of topless 17 year old = sick pervert, on to the
> SOR and don't ever think of working with children
>
> Download full colour videos of people being tortured, maimed or killed
> = no problem!
>
> If people hadn't ground Ogrish to a halt to download the Nick Berg
> beheading video then maybe Ken Bigley wouldn't have suffered the same
> fate.
>
What arrant brainless puerile drivel.  There were show terrorist murders 
before the internet - remember Aldo Moro?  The political impact of Ken 
Bigley's murder would be undimished if there had been no internet.

> Therefore I say we round up all the several hundred thousand
> sickos in this country who viewed it and charge them before putting
> them on some sort of violent offenders register.
>
Meanwhile the police have even less time to investigate violent assaults. 
What a wonderful plan you've come up with to increase the violent crime rate 
in the UK.

I say round up the the haters of freedom and place then in a big camp so 
that they can inform on each other.  This will then allow the productive 
mebers of society to get on with our lives unharrassed by this pea-brained 
trash.
date: Sat, 14 Jan 2006 10:48:01 -0000   author:   Harry The Horse

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 10:48:01 -0000, "Harry The Horse"
 wrote:

>ed wrote:
>>
>> Well, download pics of topless 17 year old = sick pervert, on to the
>> SOR and don't ever think of working with children
>>
>> Download full colour videos of people being tortured, maimed or killed
>> = no problem!
>>
>> If people hadn't ground Ogrish to a halt to download the Nick Berg
>> beheading video then maybe Ken Bigley wouldn't have suffered the same
>> fate.
>>
>What arrant brainless puerile drivel.  There were show terrorist murders 
>before the internet - remember Aldo Moro?  The political impact of Ken 
>Bigley's murder would be undimished if there had been no internet.
>
>> Therefore I say we round up all the several hundred thousand
>> sickos in this country who viewed it and charge them before putting
>> them on some sort of violent offenders register.
>>
>Meanwhile the police have even less time to investigate violent assaults. 
>What a wonderful plan you've come up with to increase the violent crime rate 
>in the UK.
>

The post was tongue in cheek. But I do believe that the huge audience
for the beheading videos has encouraged others to do the same.
date: Sat, 14 Jan 2006 11:12:28 GMT   author:   ds

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
ds wrote:
> On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 10:48:01 -0000, "Harry The Horse"
>  wrote:
>
>> ed wrote:
>>>
>>> Well, download pics of topless 17 year old = sick pervert, on to the
>>> SOR and don't ever think of working with children
>>>
>>> Download full colour videos of people being tortured, maimed or
>>> killed = no problem!
>>>
>>> If people hadn't ground Ogrish to a halt to download the Nick Berg
>>> beheading video then maybe Ken Bigley wouldn't have suffered the
>>> same fate.
>>>
>> What arrant brainless puerile drivel.  There were show terrorist
>> murders before the internet - remember Aldo Moro?  The political
>> impact of Ken Bigley's murder would be undimished if there had been
>> no internet.
>>
>>> Therefore I say we round up all the several hundred thousand
>>> sickos in this country who viewed it and charge them before putting
>>> them on some sort of violent offenders register.
>>>
>> Meanwhile the police have even less time to investigate violent
>> assaults. What a wonderful plan you've come up with to increase the
>> violent crime rate in the UK.
>>
>
> The post was tongue in cheek. But I do believe that the huge audience
> for the beheading videos has encouraged others to do the same.
>
Sorry.  With so many extreme positions being touted by government, satire 
has a tough job being recognised as such.
date: Sat, 14 Jan 2006 13:10:52 -0000   author:   Harry The Horse

Re: Ogrish and the parallel between child porn and images of violence   
On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 13:10:52 -0000, "Harry The Horse"
 wrote:


>> The post was tongue in cheek. But I do believe that the huge audience
>> for the beheading videos has encouraged others to do the same.
>>
>Sorry.  With so many extreme positions being touted by government, satire 
>has a tough job being recognised as such.
>

You're dead right there.
date: Sat, 14 Jan 2006 14:37:54 +0000   author:   ed

Google
 
Web myreader.co.uk


    COPYRIGHT 2007, YARDI TECHNOLOGY LIMITED, ALL RIGHT RESERVE  |   contact us