|
|
|
date: Mon, 21 Apr 2008 19:42:55 GMT,
group: uk.politics.animals
back
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
"pearl" wrote in message
news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
> "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
> news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>
>> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
>> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
>> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
>> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
>> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
>> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>
> See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>
>> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
>
> http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>
> ... etc.
Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
date: Mon, 21 Apr 2008 19:42:55 GMT
author: Chom Noamsky
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
Chom Noamsky wrote:
> "pearl" wrote in message
> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>> "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>> news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>>
>>> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
>>> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
>>> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
>>> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
>>> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
>>> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>> See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>>
>>> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
>> http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>>
>> ... etc.
>
> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
Yes. It's nauseating. She doesn't merely parrot it, she slavishly does
the really annoying copypasta.
date: Mon, 21 Apr 2008 12:52:16 -0700
author: Rudy Canoza
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
"Chom Noamsky" wrote in message news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
> "pearl" wrote in message
> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
> >
> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
> >
> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
> >
> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
> >
> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
> >
> > ... etc.
>
> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
You need to address the content of both those pages.
date: Tue, 22 Apr 2008 13:07:59 +0100
author: pearl
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
"pearl" wrote in message
news:fukkb1$v8u$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
> "Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
> news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
>> "pearl" wrote in message
>> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>> >
>> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
>> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
>> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
>> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
>> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
>> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>> >
>> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>> >
>> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
>> >
>> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>> >
>> > ... etc.
>>
>> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
>
> The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
>
> You need to address the content of both those pages.
And I will certainly do that, right after you prove Farley Mowat's assertion
of 40 million seals. You uncritically accept Mowat's number, then claim
that seal population modeling is uncertain.
Note to self: to defeat the likes of pearlie, just give them an audience and
eventually they will defeat themselves.
date: Tue, 22 Apr 2008 16:55:36 GMT
author: Chom Noamsky
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
"Chom Noamsky" wrote in message news:cMoPj.1201$PM5.325@edtnps92...
>
> "pearl" wrote in message
> news:fukkb1$v8u$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
> > "Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
> > news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
> >> "pearl" wrote in message
> >> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
> >> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
> >> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
> >> >
> >> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
> >> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
> >> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
> >> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
> >> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
> >> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
> >> >
> >> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
> >> >
> >> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
> >> >
> >> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
> >> >
> >> > ... etc.
> >>
> >> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
> >
> > The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
> >
> > You need to address the content of both those pages.
>
> And I will certainly do that, right after
This excuse absolutely takes the cake. An amazing show.
> you prove Farley Mowat's assertion of 40 million seals.
Go read what you can of the book, as I've been asking you to.
What you'll find is that Atlantic seal populations were ravaged.
> You uncritically accept Mowat's number, then claim
> that seal population modeling is uncertain.
I critically accept that number, and it's not me making 'claims'.
> Note to self: to defeat the likes of pearlie, just give them an audience and
> eventually they will defeat themselves.
Note to nomsky: no one's buying it, and false posturing bites.
date: Wed, 23 Apr 2008 15:08:19 +0100
author: pearl
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 15:08:19 +0100, "pearl"
wrote:
>"Chom Noamsky" wrote in message news:cMoPj.1201$PM5.325@edtnps92...
>>
>> "pearl" wrote in message
>> news:fukkb1$v8u$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>> > "Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
>> > news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
>> >> "pearl" wrote in message
>> >> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>> >> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>> >> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>> >> >
>> >> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large
>> >> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an acceptably
>> >> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it
>> >> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries
>> >> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt
>> >> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>> >> >
>> >> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>> >> >
>> >> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound conservation
>> >> >
>> >> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>> >> >
>> >> > ... etc.
>> >>
>> >> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
>> >
>> > The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
>> >
>> > You need to address the content of both those pages.
>>
>> And I will certainly do that, right after
>
>This excuse absolutely takes the cake. An amazing show.
>
>> you prove Farley Mowat's assertion of 40 million seals.
>
>Go read what you can of the book, as I've been asking you to.
>What you'll find is that Atlantic seal populations were ravaged.
>
Pearl, go and count the damn things and stop depending on what other
people say.
date: Wed, 23 Apr 2008 16:38:27 -0300
author: Paul Morgan
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
"Paul Morgan" wrote in message
news:804v041m67dj1tujstbbaqmld9koekuo64@4ax.com...
> On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 15:08:19 +0100, "pearl"
> wrote:
>
>>"Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
>>news:cMoPj.1201$PM5.325@edtnps92...
>>>
>>> "pearl" wrote in message
>>> news:fukkb1$v8u$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>>> > "Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
>>> > news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
>>> >> "pearl" wrote in message
>>> >> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>>> >> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>>> >> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>>> >> >
>>> >> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the
>>> >> >> large
>>> >> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an
>>> >> >> acceptably
>>> >> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals
>>> >> >> it
>>> >> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of
>>> >> >> Fisheries
>>> >> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the
>>> >> >> hunt
>>> >> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>>> >> >
>>> >> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>>> >> >
>>> >> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound
>>> >> >> conservation
>>> >> >
>>> >> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>>> >> >
>>> >> > ... etc.
>>> >>
>>> >> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
>>> >
>>> > The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
>>> >
>>> > You need to address the content of both those pages.
>>>
>>> And I will certainly do that, right after
>>
>>This excuse absolutely takes the cake. An amazing show.
>>
>>> you prove Farley Mowat's assertion of 40 million seals.
>>
>>Go read what you can of the book, as I've been asking you to.
>>What you'll find is that Atlantic seal populations were ravaged.
>>
>
> Pearl, go and count the damn things and stop depending on what other
> people say.
Pearl's religion has declared seals are sacred. Like most religions, hers
is based on faith rather than evidence. You might as well ask a Hindu his
opinion of beef and the best way to kill a cow.
date: Wed, 23 Apr 2008 19:55:55 GMT
author: Chom Noamsky
|
Re: No Escape for Seal Pups
On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 19:55:55 GMT, "Chom Noamsky" wrote:
>
>"Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>news:804v041m67dj1tujstbbaqmld9koekuo64@4ax.com...
>> On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 15:08:19 +0100, "pearl"
>> wrote:
>>
>>>"Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
>>>news:cMoPj.1201$PM5.325@edtnps92...
>>>>
>>>> "pearl" wrote in message
>>>> news:fukkb1$v8u$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>>>> > "Chom Noamsky" wrote in message
>>>> > news:376Pj.1145$XI1.614@edtnps91...
>>>> >> "pearl" wrote in message
>>>> >> news:fuiprg$5vd$1@reader01.news.esat.net...
>>>> >> > "Paul Morgan" wrote in message
>>>> >> > news:8fop04l74lfhiffanjf936453i920ed25a@4ax.com...
>>>> >> >
>>>> >> >> A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the
>>>> >> >> large
>>>> >> >> majority of seals taken during this hunt . are killed in an
>>>> >> >> acceptably
>>>> >> >> humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals
>>>> >> >> it
>>>> >> >> examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of
>>>> >> >> Fisheries
>>>> >> >> and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the
>>>> >> >> hunt
>>>> >> >> opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty.
>>>> >> >
>>>> >> > See: http://tinyurl.com/3ruvw5 .
>>>> >> >
>>>> >> >> "The commercial seal quota is established based on sound
>>>> >> >> conservation
>>>> >> >
>>>> >> > http://www.boycott-canada.com/assets/docs/Harp%20seal%20modelling%20report%20final%20final.doc
>>>> >> >
>>>> >> > ... etc.
>>>> >>
>>>> >> Pearl, is that all you can do, parrot ARA propaganda?
>>>> >
>>>> > The only propaganda I see here is what I left in of yours.
>>>> >
>>>> > You need to address the content of both those pages.
>>>>
>>>> And I will certainly do that, right after
>>>
>>>This excuse absolutely takes the cake. An amazing show.
>>>
>>>> you prove Farley Mowat's assertion of 40 million seals.
>>>
>>>Go read what you can of the book, as I've been asking you to.
>>>What you'll find is that Atlantic seal populations were ravaged.
>>>
>>
>> Pearl, go and count the damn things and stop depending on what other
>> people say.
>
>Pearl's religion has declared seals are sacred. Like most religions, hers
>is based on faith rather than evidence. You might as well ask a Hindu his
>opinion of beef and the best way to kill a cow.
>
Just like a religion I wonder how much money she has sent to Watson.
date: Wed, 23 Apr 2008 18:28:51 -0300
author: Paul Morgan
|
|
|
